Skip to content
3 Good Reasons to Hate Maslow's Pyramid

3 Good Reasons to Hate Maslow's Pyramid

Maslow's hierarchy of needs: the 5 levels, the origin of a pyramid Maslow never drew, its limits and what managers can still take from it.

Contact Us

Maslow's hierarchy of needs, usually drawn as a pyramid, sorts human needs into five levels: physiological needs at the base, then safety, belonging, esteem and, at the top, self-actualization. Companies refer to it whenever motivation comes up. Yet its author never spoke of a pyramid, and his theory has never been proven. Let us look again at the key ideas of his founding article, and at what a manager can still take from it.

Topic
Employee Motivation
Reading time
17 min
Updated
16 October 2026

Maslow's pyramid in brief: the 5 levels of needs

Here are the five levels as they are usually presented, with what each one means in working life:

  1. physiological needs: eating, drinking, sleeping, keeping warm. At work, this means a salary you can live on, manageable hours and a job that does not put your health at risk;
  2. safety needs: feeling protected and being able to plan ahead. At work, a stable contract, clear rules and an organization that does not change course every three months;
  3. belonging needs: being accepted and mattering to others. At work, a team where you have your place and colleagues you can rely on;
  4. esteem needs: being recognized by others and respecting yourself. At work, recognition from your manager and peers, and responsibilities that match your skills;
  5. self-actualization: becoming what you are capable of being. At work, learning, creating and taking on challenges that mean something to you.
On this page16 sections
  1. 01The five levels of Maslow's hierarchy of needs in detail
  2. 02Deficiency needs and growth needs
  3. 03Self-transcendence: the forgotten sixth level
  4. 04Who was Abraham Maslow?
  5. 05The origins of A. Maslow's article
  6. 06Reason 1: a theory of human motivation, not a theory of management
  7. 07Reason 2: Maslow never talked about a pyramid
  8. 08Reason 3: the theory behind Maslow's pyramid has not been scientifically validated
  9. 09What Maslow's pyramid still offers managers
  10. 10Examples of Maslow's hierarchy of needs
  11. 11Using the hierarchy as a practical check at work
  12. 12Maslow's hierarchy of needs compared with other theories of motivation
  13. 13How Maslow's hierarchy of needs is used outside companies
  14. 14Children, safety and the 1943 article
  15. 15Motivating a team without a ready-made pyramid
  16. 16Frequently asked questions about Maslow's hierarchy of needs

The principle is simple: as long as a basic need is unmet, it takes centre stage; once it is satisfied, it stops motivating and makes way for the next one. That simplicity is what made the model so successful. It is also what makes it a problem.

The five levels of Maslow's hierarchy of needs in detail

The short list above hides a good deal of nuance about human needs. Here is what Maslow actually put behind each level, and how each need tends to show up in a person's working life.

Physiological needs: survival first

At the base, physiological needs include everything related to physical survival: food, water, shelter, sleep, warmth and, in Maslow's own list, sex. They are the most powerful of all when they are not met. Maslow notes that for someone who is chronically hungry, the whole of life comes down to food, and every other goal fades into the background. In a modern company these needs are usually covered, but not always: night shifts, long commutes, chronic lack of sleep or pay that barely covers the rent all bring them back into focus.

Safety needs: a predictable environment

Once the body is looked after, the person looks for security: physical safety, health, a stable income, protection against the unexpected, an environment that is orderly and predictable. Maslow saw the preference for a secure job and for insurance as everyday expressions of this need. At work, it is threatened by restructuring, unclear rules, short-term contracts and the chronic stress of not knowing what tomorrow will bring.

Love and belonging: social needs

The third level covers social needs: friendship, intimacy, family, and the sense of being part of a group. Maslow speaks of a hunger for affectionate relations with people in general, for a place in one's group. In a team, belongingness shows in the quality of relationships between colleagues, in the welcome given to newcomers and in the way people who work remotely are included, or forgotten.

Esteem needs: respect from oneself and from others

Maslow divides esteem needs into two related sets. The first is self-esteem: the desire for achievement, mastery, competence and independence. The second is the esteem of others: reputation, status, prestige, recognition and appreciation. When these needs are met, the person feels useful and capable; when they are not, Maslow describes feelings of inferiority and helplessness. For a manager, this is the level where specific, sincere recognition makes the biggest difference.

Self-actualization: becoming who you are

At the top, self-actualization is the desire to realize one's potential. Maslow sums it up in a famous line: "What a man can be, he must be." It takes very different forms from one person to another: for one it is learning and mastering a craft, for another creating something new, for a third bringing up children well. Unlike the lower levels, it is never complete: personal growth is a direction rather than a destination.

Deficiency needs and growth needs

In "Toward a Psychology of Being" (1962), Maslow refined his model. He called the four lower-level needs deficiency needs: they arise from a lack, motivate people as long as they are unmet, and fall silent once they are satisfied. Self-actualization, by contrast, belongs to the growth needs, sometimes called being needs: they do not come from a lack, and the more they are fed, the stronger they become. Someone who loves learning wants to learn more, not less. Once a person's basic needs are met, higher-level needs come to the fore.

This distinction is probably more useful to managers than the pyramid itself. It explains why a bonus can calm a sense of injustice without creating lasting drive, while an interesting project can sustain motivation and effort for years. It also explains a common mistake: offering growth opportunities to a person whose basic needs are under threat, or the reverse, offering security to someone who mostly wants to learn.

Maslow also saw the hierarchy from a developmental perspective. Higher needs tend to emerge as lower ones are met over the course of a life, but individuals can move back down the levels at any time: a redundancy, an illness or a divorce can bring safety or belonging back to the top of a person's concerns, whatever their age or position.

Self-transcendence: the forgotten sixth level

In his later writings, at the end of the 1960s, Maslow went beyond self-actualization and described a further motive: self-transcendence, the commitment to a cause or a goal beyond oneself, such as serving others, an ideal or a sense of meaning. These ideas were published after his death in "The Farther Reaches of Human Nature" (1971). In 2006, the psychologist Mark Koltko-Rivera argued that this level should be added to the standard model, which is why some textbooks now show a pyramid with six levels. This line of thought also led Maslow, with Anthony Sutich, to launch the Journal of Transpersonal Psychology in 1969, after co-founding the Journal of Humanistic Psychology in 1961.

Who was Abraham Maslow?

Abraham Maslow was born in Brooklyn in 1908, the son of Jewish immigrants from the Russian Empire. After studying psychology, he taught at Brooklyn College and then, from 1951, at Brandeis University near Boston. With Carl Rogers, he was one of the founders of humanistic psychology, a school that looked less at disorders than at what helps a healthy person grow. For "Motivation and Personality" (1954), he studied the lives of people he considered self-actualized, among them Abraham Lincoln, Albert Einstein and Eleanor Roosevelt. He became president of the American Psychological Association in the late 1960s and died in California in 1970. His analysis of human motives remains one of the most quoted in the history of psychology, which is precisely why it deserves to be read carefully rather than reduced to a drawing.

The origins of A. Maslow's article

Let us first understand why this article, written in July 1943 by Abraham Maslow, still carries so much weight in companies today. As soon as management training comes up, people think of Maslow's pyramid. On one point I agree with most of my fellow consultants, trainers and coaches: motivation remains a crucial lever in management. But you still need to know what really motivates an employee today, and that is exactly where the famous pyramid shows its limits.

Reason 1: a theory of human motivation, not a theory of management

It is July 1943. When his article "A Theory of Human Motivation" appears in the journal Psychological Review, Maslow is a professor at Brooklyn College in New York. The Second World War is at its height: the Soviets have just defeated the troops of the Third Reich at Stalingrad. Managing teams is not the concern of the moment.

Maslow writes as a clinical psychologist. He draws on what he observes in his patients and on the authors of his time, Freud, Adler and Goldstein. Work only appears in passing in his text, in connection with the need for safety, when he mentions the preference for a secure job, a savings account or insurance. Nothing about managers, organizations or performance.

The move into business came later, through other people. In 1960, Douglas McGregor published "The Human Side of Enterprise", in which his well-known Theory X and Theory Y draw directly on the hierarchy of needs. The model then entered business schools. Maslow himself took an interest in 1962, during a summer spent at a Californian electronics company, Non-Linear Systems. He drew a book from it, "Eupsychian Management" (1965), in which he worried about enthusiastic executives adopting wholesale a model that came from the clinic and had never been tested in the world of work. The author was therefore the first to urge caution.

Reason 2: Maslow never talked about a pyramid

Nowhere in his article does Abraham Maslow use the word "pyramid". He talks about a hierarchy of needs, which is not the same thing. To take a rigorous approach, we ranked the words of his article by semantic analysis. Out of the 9,102 words in the July 1943 text, here are the rank and number of occurrences of a few significant words, the top places being taken by English function words (the, of, and…).

RankWord in the articleOccurrences
9needs129
19basic68
26behavior47
40theory36
48safety30
49motivation30
50love29
51physiological29
65satisfied23
71hunger20
86esteem15
88hierarchy15
—pyramid0

The word "needs" ranks 9th, with 129 occurrences. "Hierarchy" only comes in at 88th, with 15 occurrences. As for "pyramid", it does not appear once.

Above all, the hierarchy Maslow describes is anything but rigid. He devotes a whole section of his article to exceptions: people for whom self-esteem matters more than love, creative people who create whatever their living conditions, people ready to sacrifice everything for an ideal. He also points out that a need does not have to be fully satisfied for the next one to emerge. A pyramid with neatly separated levels says exactly the opposite.

We must therefore accept that the pyramid was not born of Maslow's work: other authors added it over the years. In 2019, three management researchers, Todd Bridgman, Stephen Cummings and John Ballard, traced its history: the triangle appears in the management literature around the turn of the 1960s, then spreads from textbook to textbook until it becomes the image everyone knows. Maslow himself spoke of a hierarchy and of the satisfaction of needs. His article was above all exploratory research into the psychological needs of human beings.

Reason 3: the theory behind Maslow's pyramid has not been scientifically validated

The period was hardly suited to validating anything: in 1943 resources were mobilized elsewhere, and checking that human needs fall into five ranked categories would have required lengthy research. That research was carried out later, and its results are disappointing.

  • The AT&T managers: in 1968, Douglas Hall and Khalil Nougaim followed around fifty young managers for five years. Their needs changed as their careers developed, but not in the order the hierarchy predicts.
  • Two levels rather than five: in 1972, Edward Lawler and Lloyd Suttle concluded, at best, that there is a distinction between basic needs and all the others, with no established order above them.
  • A pyramid to rebuild: in 2010, Douglas Kenrick and his colleagues proposed rebuilding it entirely on the basis of evolutionary psychology, with needs that overlap instead of stacking up.

To these findings I would add a criticism I come across every day in my work. As early as 1980, Geert Hofstede pointed out that Maslow's hierarchy reflects the values of the American middle class of his time. In cultures where the group comes before the individual, belonging and safety often matter more than personal achievement. A manager leading an international team soon notices this.

It is therefore a theory, or rather a hypothesis, never backed by solid scientific evidence. I stay cautious: when I mention Maslow in management training, I keep my claims measured. There is other research on motivation that is better suited to managers' everyday reality, notably Herzberg's work, Deci and Ryan's self-determination theory, or Spranger's theory of motivations.

What Maslow's pyramid still offers managers

Hating the pyramid does not mean throwing Maslow away. Three ideas from his article remain valuable for anyone leading a team, and they are the useful core of Maslow's hierarchy of needs in the workplace.

  • A threatened need takes up all the space. An employee who fears for their job in the middle of a reorganization will not hear a speech about the purpose of the mission. Before talking about ambition, you have to address the worry.
  • A satisfied need stops motivating. A pay rise is welcome, then becomes the norm. Relying on salary alone to sustain engagement is like filling a leaking bucket.
  • The lasting levers are at the top. Recognition, autonomy and the chance to learn keep motivation going over time, provided the foundations are solid.

On the other hand, the pyramid says nothing about the differences between people. Two employees in the same role, on the same salary, can be driven by opposite motives. When an important need stays frustrated for too long, either of them may end up sliding into demotivation, but not for the same reasons. That difference is what a manager has to understand, case by case, rather than assuming that everyone climbs the same pyramid at the same pace.

Examples of Maslow's hierarchy of needs

Concrete examples make the five levels easier to grasp. The same person can sit at different levels in different areas of life at the same time.

  • Physiological needs: an employee on night shifts who cannot sleep properly, or someone who skips meals to meet deadlines. Until these physiological needs are met, talk of motivation has little effect.
  • Safety needs: a team waiting for the outcome of a merger, or a contractor who does not know whether their contract will be renewed. The search for security shapes what they do, and stress rises.
  • Love and belonging: a remote employee who never meets colleagues, or a newcomer left alone at lunch. Their belonging needs are not met, and they feel like outsiders.
  • Esteem needs: an expert whose work is always presented by someone else, or a manager whose status is questioned after a reorganization. Self-esteem and the esteem of others both suffer.
  • Self-actualization: an engineer who wants to take on a new technical challenge, or a person who goes back to studying in mid-career. These higher-level needs drive personal growth and learning.

In each case, the hierarchy of needs offers a useful reading grid for a first analysis, as long as you remember that human needs rarely line up as neatly as the pyramid suggests. A person can be strongly driven by learning while their physical health or financial security is under strain: real life looks more like a web of related needs than a staircase.

Using the hierarchy as a practical check at work

Used as a checklist rather than a law, Maslow's hierarchy of needs in the workplace helps a manager ask the right questions about each person. A few examples, from lower-level needs to higher-level needs:

  • Physiological and physical needs: are workload and hours compatible with good health? Persistent stress, poor sleep and exhausting effort over long periods undermine everything else.
  • Safety needs: does each person understand what is expected of them, and what the next six months hold? An environment where goals change every week keeps people in survival mode.
  • Social needs and belongingness: does everyone have a real place in the team, including new arrivals and remote staff? Social isolation is one of the quietest forms of demotivation.
  • Esteem needs: is effort recognized, and is status attributed fairly? Individuals notice very quickly when recognition always goes to the same people.
  • Self-actualization and growth: can people keep learning, set some of their own goals and use their talents? Different individuals will answer this in very different ways.

The answers will differ from one person to another, and that is the point. Two individuals at the same level of the hierarchy can have very different motives: one seeks status, the other learning; one is driven by goals, the other by the quality of social relationships. Maslow's own analysis of human motives allowed for this diversity far more than the pyramid suggests.

Maslow's hierarchy of needs compared with other theories of motivation

Maslow's theory of human motivation was the first of a long line. Several later models kept some of his ideas and corrected others, and a manager gains a lot from knowing them side by side.

Alderfer's ERG theory

In 1969, the psychologist Clayton Alderfer reduced Maslow's five levels to three groups of needs: existence (physiological and safety needs), relatedness (social and esteem needs from others) and growth (self-esteem and self-actualization). His main change was to drop the strict order. Several needs can be active at the same time, and when higher-level needs are frustrated, a person may fall back on lower-level ones: someone who sees no way to grow in their job may start to focus on pay and status instead. This frustration and regression principle matches what many managers see every day.

Herzberg's two-factor theory

Frederick Herzberg, in 1959, looked at what people actually describe when they talk about good and bad periods at work. Hygiene factors such as pay, working conditions, job security and relations with management prevent dissatisfaction but do not motivate. Motivators such as achievement, recognition, responsibility and the work itself create real drive. Herzberg's hygiene factors roughly cover Maslow's lower levels, and his motivators the higher ones, but he showed that the two sets act on different feelings rather than on a single scale.

McClelland's theory of needs

David McClelland, whose book "The Achieving Society" appeared in 1961, focused on three learned needs: achievement, affiliation and power. Unlike Maslow, he saw them less as universal stages than as individual profiles shaped by life experience. One person is driven above all by the need to succeed at difficult goals, another by the need for warm relationships, a third by the need for influence. For a manager, this is a strong reminder that the same level of the hierarchy can hide very different motives.

Self-determination theory

Edward Deci and Richard Ryan's self-determination theory, developed from the 1980s onwards, identifies three basic psychological needs: autonomy, competence and relatedness. It does not rank them. When these needs are met, people tend to be more motivated, more persistent and in better psychological health; when they are frustrated, motivation becomes more fragile and more dependent on external rewards. Of all the models, it is probably the one with the strongest research base today.

How Maslow's hierarchy of needs is used outside companies

The success of Maslow's hierarchy of needs goes far beyond management, which partly explains why the pyramid is so familiar. Three fields use it every day.

  • Education: teachers often sum up the idea as "Maslow before Bloom": a child who is hungry, tired or afraid cannot concentrate on learning. Free school breakfasts and attention to pupils' sense of safety and belonging at school are direct applications of the lower levels.
  • Health care and nursing: nurses learn to set priorities with the hierarchy in mind. Physiological needs such as breathing, food, water and pain relief come first, then physical safety, before the patient's social and psychological needs can be properly addressed.
  • Marketing: brands position their products on the level of need they claim to meet, from food and comfort to security, social status or personal growth. A car can be sold as a safe way to protect a family or as a symbol of success.

These uses show both the strength and the limit of the model. As a simple reminder of human needs, it works remarkably well. As a precise description of how each individual sets priorities, it says much less.

Children, safety and the 1943 article

Many readers are surprised to find that Maslow's article spends a long time on children. To illustrate the safety needs, he explains that the average child prefers a safe, orderly and predictable world, and reacts to sudden noise, illness, family quarrels or a change of routine as if the whole world had become unsafe. Adults, he says, have learned to hide these reactions, but the need is the same.

This developmental view is one of the most useful parts of his analysis. It reminds managers that safety needs do not disappear with age: they are simply better hidden. In periods of change, adults react in ways that are very close to what Maslow described in children, and clear information, stable routines and visible support from the manager reduce stress more effectively than any speech about the future.

Motivating a team without a ready-made pyramid

There are many ways to build your team's motivation without forcing a model onto people who do not recognize themselves in it. We work with teams through team coaching and team building, including in multicultural settings. Do get in touch to talk it over.

Frequently asked questions about Maslow's hierarchy of needs

What are the 5 levels of Maslow's hierarchy of needs?

From the base to the top: physiological needs, safety needs, belonging needs, esteem needs and self-actualization. Maslow later distinguished deficiency needs, the first four, which motivate as long as they are unmet, from growth needs, which keep motivating once satisfied. Towards the end of his life he also mentioned an additional level, self-transcendence, often presented as a sixth tier.

Who invented Maslow's pyramid?

Not Maslow. In 1943 he described a hierarchy of needs, without ever drawing it or using the word pyramid. The triangle appears in the management literature around the turn of the 1960s, then spreads through textbooks and training courses. It made the idea famous, but it also hardened its meaning.

Is Maslow's hierarchy of needs still valid today?

As a lens, yes: it reminds us that frustrated basic needs make it hard to think about anything else. As a theory, no: studies have never confirmed the strict order of the five levels, and the model reflects an individualistic culture that does not apply everywhere. It is better used to ask questions than to provide answers.

How can you use Maslow's hierarchy of needs at work?

As a checklist rather than a staircase. A manager can check, for each employee, that pay and working conditions are adequate, that the future of the role is clear, that the person has their place in the team, that they receive recognition and that they can grow. To go further, you then need to understand what motivates each individual, which the pyramid cannot do.

What is the difference between Maslow's hierarchy and Herzberg's theory?

Maslow places needs on a single scale. Herzberg, in 1959, separated two families of factors: those that prevent dissatisfaction, such as pay or working conditions, and those that create motivation, such as recognition or interesting work. For a manager, Herzberg is often more directly useful, because he explains why a well-paid employee can still be demotivated.

What is the difference between Maslow's hierarchy and Alderfer's ERG theory?

Alderfer grouped Maslow's five levels into three sets of needs: existence, relatedness and growth. He dropped the strict order, accepted that several needs can drive behaviour at once, and added the idea that a person frustrated in higher-level needs may fall back on lower-level ones.

Further reading

The topic of this pageEmployee MotivationMotivation in the workplace: intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, practical levers, Spranger's six motivations and a free test to find out what drives you.
Portrait of Marc Prager

This article was written by

Marc Prager

My dual background as an operational leader and a coach lets me connect strategic vision with personal development. Every engagement starts by genuinely listening to the organisation’s challenges and culture, and draws on proven tools: DISC profile, 16 personality types, Hogan, 360-degree feedback. I am also a partner in Cadran, International Executive Coaching.

Regions
Middle East, Central Asia, Russia, Europe
Certification
ICF PCC Executive Coach
Education
Master’s in HR Management, HEC Paris
Firm
Founded in 2015, partner at Cadran